American Idol 2009 Top 10 Elimination Results – March 26, 2009

Tonight on American Idol 2009, the elimination results for this season’s Top 10 will be revealed. Stay tuned…

American Idol 2009 Top 10 Elimination Results:

  • Michael Sarver

After coming down to the bottom 3 of Scott McIntyre, Michael Sarver, and Matt Giraud it was revealed that Michael had earned the fewest votes after this week’s performance show. Michael sang for his Idol-life, but it was not enough.

Michael Sarver has been eliminated from American Idol 2009.

Do you think America made the right choice? Share your thoughts!

FROM THE WEB

FROM THE WEB

JOIN THE DISCUSSION

93 Comments

  1. i honestly think megan was suppose to go the girl sang like a amateur. micheal was not as bad as her and she still didnt get in the bottom three. Please these votes are rigged or people just dont know good music when they hear it. As long as Adam and Danny are in it that is all I care about because they have talent but if it was fair the blonde would be gone!!

  2. i´m so happy!!!!!!!megan is still on the competition!!! I know she was no good last week due to her song choice, but she is much much better then Sarver and MCINTYRE!!! I think Adam soon will be dressed up as Victor Victoria or Lisa!!! jajajja

  3. Yes, I think Megan should have gone too ~ there must be lots of men voting! And how did Matt get in the Bottom 3??? Strange!

    My faves are Danny and Kris.

  4. If I had my druthers, I’d send ADAM home in a heartbeat ~ but that ain’t gonna happen! I’m hoping for a “shocker elimination” after the Top 5!

  5. It should have been between Micheal and Megan because they are great singers but neither did well this week. Though I don’t think that Matt had any business being in the bottom 3 either.

  6. Meagan Really needs to go. The judges should have saved Michael Sarver. And NO WAY SHOULD ADAM GO HOME….He has proved to be a GREAT ARTIST….

  7. That Megan was not in the bottom three was stunning. I had Mike and Megan as the bottom two, with a poor performance by Lil driving her lower in the voting. Does anyone but me think Adam looks like a young Elvis?

  8. Sarver had to go. Scott should be next. Meagan is
    A: Totally different and quirky. the other two are not. Michael is a nice guy, but seen his type a million times. Scott is not great shakes, kinda reminds me of David Naughton. (a Big load of Naughton)
    B: She’s a super hottie (gotta wear a sleeve, hate the tat) Micheal and Scott (Yikes!)
    C; Just like Lil should have had a “MOMENT” with Mowtown Week, Meagan just needs to find the right song, and she could really have one of those amazing, whole-nother-level Adamesque MOMENTS.

  9. And Paolo, Last night Adam looked like Kurt Russell playing Elvis in 1979’s ELvis: the Movie.

  10. How did Matt get into the bottom three?!? He should make it to the top five. Scott and Megan are next. Sarver should not have gone yet.

  11. There is a great deal of other factors that play in to what the common public does not see. What has transpired this week, although very entertaining, was a bit disappointing…never would have dreamed when the group came together for tonight’s performance that it would seem as if they were lip-synching……Is it Live or is it Memorex?

  12. I thought Adam looked like Elvis too! I really thought it would be Megan, Michael and Scott in the bottom three. You just never know. I guess this is why they have the new rule!

  13. I do not understand how Scott McIntyre and Megan Gokey are in the top 10 and how they stay in the competition. Am I
    missing something. I do feel like Michael Sarver should have gone home but for the life of me I do not understand how these two are still here and of all things will be on the tour.I went and saw the tour in Houston, TX last Summer and all performers were outstanding. I really do not see myself going this year with these two in the top 10. Can someone please explain it to me?

  14. Yes I think Megan should have gone!!!
    Does it bother anyone else the way Paula and Simon act? Talk about NO CLASS!!!

  15. Stevie should have sang Buddy Weaver’s “Ba Rock Around The Clock,” or Michael Jackson’s “Ba Rock With You,” perhaps Simon & Garfunkel’s “I Am Ba Rock,” but when the Prez gets done with his “Chicago-style” leadership, the finale may end with “Jailhouse Ba Rock.”

  16. oh my my god im surprice math is in bottom3. i cant believe it.megan is deserving to be top 3 she pretty but shes sing like an amatuer

  17. I think that Michael should have not went home. I think he did a great job. I can’t believe Matt was in the bottom three, he was awesome. I don’t think Scott did a good job this week and he should have went home instead of Michael.

  18. I think Meagan should have went home. She was horrible and Michael was far more better than her. Michael shouldn’t have even been in the bottom three neither should Matt.

  19. Agreed, Megan should have gone home last night. The bottom 3 I expected were Michael, Megan and Scott. As much as I like Scott, he just can’t hit the notes. Adam surpasses my expectations every week with his versatility. I doubt highly that the judges will use the save until the top four or five.

  20. Oh my gosh I was floored when Matt was in the bottom 3. What is up with that!!! Megan needs to go.

  21. America made the right choice but what are they waiting on to send Megan home? Matt should never have been in the bottom 3. He looks to be a top 4 competitor and Megan is in it because of her looks. SHE CAN’T SING OR DANCE FOR THAT MATTER!!! GO HOME MEGAN!

  22. MEGAN NEEDS TO GO RIGHT NOW SHE CAN’T SING, SHE CAN’T DANCE, EVERY TIME SHE WIGGLES IT LOOKS LIKE SHE’S TRYING TO SHAKE A TURD LOOSE. GET HER OFF THE SHOW NOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  23. Can’t believe Megan is still around–but Sarver
    needed to go—even HE looked happy to be done
    with it all. Lil is great, but she needs to up
    her game or she’ll be gone, and she really is
    very talented. Adam is amazing and so is Allison—the rest of the guys all seem the same–no one really stands out.

  24. i think meagan is different htat is why she is still ther ,as for her dancing i dont think that is what htee competition is about she can sing but not like normal people she has a jazzie type of voice which alot of people fine nice and want to see more ,she will most likly be next to go ,but i kind of like her voice ,lil has to stop yelling when she sings , and adam i predict will be the winner he is out of this world ,and with his hair back he looked like kurt russell ,

  25. megan is not different sorry the only reason she is still in it is because guys vote and her dresses and skirts get shorter and shorter even simon drools over her!!! ALEXIS was million times better then her and deserved to be in the top 10. i went to the american idol concert last year and i enjoyed it all except brooke this year the top 10 is not as good as it was last year and i think the sales will reflect that.

    Adam or Danny will win thats my guess. Danny needs to do something different tho he sings great but this week he didnt stand out. Alison and Adam are the only ones that stood out.What was up with lil this week?? this should have been her week. The last two weeks have not been great from her.

    Megan if people stop voting for her looks hopefully will be gone next week her or scott will be gone. Scott just isnt ready yet. Megan i will be glad if i never have to hear her whinny/nasal/throaty singing ever again

  26. I LOVE LIL AND I PRAY AND HOPE SHE WINS. ADAM IS GOOD BUT I DON’T PREDICT HIM WINNING. LIL DOESN’T YELL WHEN SHE SINGS SHE JUST HAS A LOUD VOICE. MEAGAN IS DIFFERENT BUT SHE’S ONLY VOTED FOR BECAUSE SHE WEARS THINGS TO SHOW HER BODY. ONE OF MY COWORKERS(A MALE) SAYS THAT SHE CAN’T SING BUT GUYS VOTE FOR HER BECAUSE OF HOW SHE DRESSES. DANNY IS GOOD BUT I DON’T THINK HE’S GOING TO WIN. I LOVE ALLISON ALSO I THINK SHE’S GOING TO BE ANOTHER KELLY CLARKSON. THE TOP 10 ARE REALLY GOOD THIS YEAR BUT THE BOYS ARE OUTWEIGHING THE GIRLS. ANOOP IS A PRETTY GOOD SINGER BUT HE HAS TO GO ALONG WITH SCOTT. SCOTT IS NICE BUT I THINK PEOPLE TAKE PITTY ON HIM BECAUSE HE’S BLIND. I FELL IN LOVE WITH MATT THIS WEEK HE REALLY “SANG.”

  27. Michael was not the best singer in the bunch. He made up for this with his personality and sheer energy. Some people might find it cruel or unfair, but Michael got Scott MacIntyre beat performance-wise and it’s not because Scott is blind. I think Scott has an unfair advantage because of the sympathy vote. Yes, it’s inspirational to see people with disabilities overcoming their shortcomings but let’s be fair when it comes to deciding who the more talented one is.

  28. MEGAN DESERVES TO BE THERE NOT BECAUSE SHE IS BEAUTIFUL, BUT BECAUSE SHE IS ORIGINAL AN CHARISMATIC, LAST WEEK WAS BAD FOR HER, BUT IS HAS HAPPENED IN OTHER SEASONS, EVEN TO THE WINNERS. SO BAD ALEXIS HAD TO GO, SHE IS MUCH BETTER THAN LIL WHO IS AVERAGE!!!! YOU DONT HAVE TO BE TOO CLEVER TO KNOW ADAM, DANNY (WHO IS GETTING VERY PREDICTABLE) AND KRIS WILL GO ON. ALLISON OUTSTANDED LAST WEEK BUT SHE REPEATS AND REPEATS HERSELF EVERYTIME AND HAS NO CHARISMA WHATSOEVER.

  29. Megan should have been voted off. This show doesn’t seem like it’s looking for the best singer. It seems like it’s looking for the most popular with America.

  30. Megan should have been voted off. This show is not looking for the best singer. It’s looking for the most popular.

  31. Unfortunately, He would have gone sometime. Megan seems too nervous. If she could calm down a little I think she would be much better.

  32. I THINK THAT IT SUCKS!!!! MICHAEL CAN SING AND PERFORM CIRCLES AROUND MEGAN………I THINK THAT 3 OUT OF 4 JUDGES WANTED TO SAVE MICHAEL, BUT THEY ARE SCARED LITTLE PUPS AROUND THE BIG BAD SIMON……..I VOTE THEY KICK HIM OFF! OUT RAGED IN WEST VIRGINIA

  33. LIL IS NOT AVERAGE. MEAGAN JUST NEEDS TO GO HOME NOW!! SHE SHOULD HAVE BEEN GONE. LIL IS A POWERFUL VOICE. STOP TRYING TO COMPARE HER TO AVERAGE.

  34. lil has a powerful voice but another powerful voice with no special style, that is why i think she is average, forgetable!!! as simon says, nothing worse than that.

  35. LIL ROUNDS DOES HAVE A SPECIAL STYLE NO PERSONS VOICE IS THE SAME SO ALL OF THEM HAVE A SPECIAL STYLE. EVEN DOWN TO MEAGAN WHO NEEDS TO GO HOME.

  36. WHATEVER I DON’T CARE I’VE LOVED LIL ROUNDS FROM WHEN SHE FIRST AUDITIONED. I’LL ALWAYS BE A LIL FAN. I LOVE MATT TOO!! AND ALLISON IS MY GIRL!!!

  37. PEACHES, BE SWEET NOT ANGRY..JAJA..IT´S OK THAT YOU LIKE AVERAGE LIL OR BORING ALLISON, I LIKE SQUIRKY MEGAN AND THATS OK. IS ALL ABOUT TASTE.

  38. I am in Guatemala watching on the internet, and at this point on, Idol is a popularity contest. Believe me!

  39. I thought Megan done the worst! She’s good – but not Idol Material. As far as the Popularity contest – it always has been! I don’t like Adam – but you can bet he will be in the Top 2! I like Matt,Danny, & Kris! Hope all three make it to the top!

  40. PEACHES, IT WAS FUN WHEN WE WERE FIGHTING!! JAJA, LET´S SEE IF ADAM COMES NEXT WEEK DRESSED AS A NUN SINGING “JESUS CHRIST SUPERSTAR”. THAT WILL DO IT DON´T YOU THINK?

  41. Girl, now you know it was fun when we were fighting. And yes that would be crazy. But I don’t think that would be a good idea. I don’t like people to make in front of my Jesus!! but i still got love for you gianna

  42. Yes. America got it right. It was not that I didn’t like his singing, but it was because he chose a song where he was bringing a girl to stay with him and the whole time he was grinning and smiling. unbelieveable.

  43. Michael was one of my bottom three. America made the right choice. Matt should not have been in the bottom 3. While Michael sang okay, his song was not believable. How can you beg a girl to stay and smile and laugh about it at the same time?

  44. Someone please explain the “Mattappeal” to me. I saw awkward dancing, albeit above average-vocals(but sub par to a lot of the others) and a lack of charisma. This show is about who will sell records. Think before you vote, maybe listen with your eyes closed! LOL…you won’t see them on a CD. Another thing.. what percentage of your life (if you really think about it) do you spend having sex? I know that who Adam prefers to do this with is really hurting him with some of you. If it is over 5% of the time, then you may need counseling. So, who someone is intimate with is really unimportant. This is a talent show, not a morality forum.

  45. This site sure has a lot to say about public education, if nothing else! Very few posts are grammatically correct, aside from spelling!

  46. at this point Megan Corkrey keeps advancing either because she’s extremely cute, or because votefortheworst.com is making it happen

  47. Megan keeps advancing because she´s cute? because votefortheworst is making it happen? or BECAUSE SHE HAS A UNIQUE VOICE AND STANDS OUT FOR HER ORIGINALITY? fOR ME, BESIDES HER AND ADAM, ALL THE REST BRING NOTHING NEW TO THE
    COMPETITION. LETS NOT FORGET DAVID ARCHULETA HAD THE VOTEFORTHEWORST VOTE AND HE WAS A GREAT SINGER, AND YES, MEGAN DID WRONG PAST WEEK, BUT GREAT THE OTHERS, ALMOST EVERY CONTESTANT EACH SEASON HAS IT´S BAD WEEK, NO MATTER HOW GOOD THEY WERE.

  48. Megan should be out definitely. I don’t know how she came into the top 13 in the first place!!! definitely it is her looks and you know… She can’t sing, she is worse than amateur. You mean singing out of tune and out of key is original??? Or is t a polite way of saying you sing out of tune!!! Ya it must be hose men who vote and eep her there.

  49. Megan should have gone. I don’t know what these people see, she can’t sing. I don’t know how she made it this far. Oh! but let me think….I’ve got it.Its beauty not talent. Come on America, we’re suppose to be looking for talent. Hopefully Megan will go next week.

  50. Still shocked how Matt was in Bottom 3,even Megan herself knows she is not that good,its visible form her reactions on Thursday,but i hope America votes for talent not beauty!
    Danny,Lil,Kris still my favorites.

  51. Michael should definitely not have been eliminated. Megan was the one to have gone – she gave an awful performance, sounded like a strangled cat!

  52. TONIGHT MEGAN IS COMING BACK AND FORTUNATELY WILL KEEP ON THE SHOW!!!!!I HOPE SHE´S COMING BACK BETTER THAN EVER SO ALL THOSE SUFFERERS ACCEPT SHE IS GREAT, ORIGINAL AND DIFFERENT.THE SAME WITH KRIS, HE HAS A UNIQUE VOICE, AND HOPE ADAM DOESN´T COME BACK TO HIS FIRST WEEKS CUSTOM. HE IS A GOOD ENTERTAINER SO HOPE HE CONTINUES TO SURPRISE US…THE REST CAN GO HOME WHENEVER THEY WANT, NO BIG DEAL!!

  53. Megan can come back all she wants she still whack. Kris is ok but he doesn’t have a strong voice and nothing is unique about it. As for Adam his voice is amazing. The rest of them are awesome especially Lil my fav and Megan can go home whenever no big deal for her!!

  54. Lil is another case of “an african american with a great voice but with no style”. Lakisha from the other idol, she got talent and style, she went wrong for the songs she chose, but a voice like that is a voice to remember!!!!

  55. Peaches, I still remember you as a very christian girl. I´M SURE EVEN YOU WILL FORGET LIL SOON.God bless!

  56. Megan has a voice of her own going on…a one hit wonder…………..Adam has improved and deserves to go on. He has a wonderful voice…
    I think to nite will tell us about Megan…if she sings like she has in the past, she needs to go………….she just needs the right song…………..and watch out, she’ll go along way….

  57. Hi, i am huge fan of the program, i really don’t understand what Megan is doing there, ok she is cute but this is not a beauty contest, i hope this will be her last week because i can’t stand her screamings, every time she appears i change chanel lol…no matter what, Adam is going to be the next and the best American Idol for sure!!
    Alma from Mexico, City

  58. Oh shutup gianna, I still remember you as a babbling butt hole. And I won’t forget Lil and God bless you too. Smart ass!

  59. Megan did a horrible job last night. She needs to be in the bottom three because her singing last night was awful. Adam did an awesome job I know he was feeling it when I saw him dancing before he even started to sing. Lil could have did better, but she still my girl.Allison always sounds good. Matt where was he last night? Scott???? Kris, oooh!! loved Kris he put it down last night.

  60. anoop- trying to be a pop star. no style
    megan- wrong song choice again!you didnt listen
    danny- a phil collins wanna be,very predictable
    allison- blueberry disaster going to the top
    lil-bad hair day! where is the wedding cake?
    scott- better but not enough to stand out.
    matt-his voice all over the place.
    IN ANOTHER LEAGUE…LAMBERT AND KRIS!!!
    kris- just beautiful! hope he goes to the top

  61. Oh shut up gianna. You know you be working on my nerves. But you might be halfway right this time. whatever!!

  62. I’m not even going to dignify anything else you say with a response. It’s really just pointless.

  63. i don’t think kris should of won adam is rlly good and when he sings he gives me goose bumps and kris just sings rlly boring! i think adam should of won hes way better than kris!

3 Trackbacks / Pingbacks

  1. American Idol 2009 Top 10 Becomes Top 9 - Official List | American Idol 2009
  2. American Idol 2009’s Michael Sarver Says ‘No More Oil Rigs’ | American Idol 2009
  3. American Idol 2009 Top 9 - The Week Ahead | American Idol 2009

Comments are closed.