Comments on: American Idol 2010: The Top 8 Guys Recap

By: Margaret

Margaret — Sat, 13 Mar 2010 05:34:32 +0000

I can’t listen to the judges this year. What the hell is going on with them?? It all sounds too weird. They have the contestants confused, never mind us. The only guy that I feel has it all, is Casey. For the women it’s Crystal and Siobhan. However, so far, Crystal is my favorite to win.

By: Coolteacher

Coolteacher — Fri, 12 Mar 2010 02:19:49 +0000

I don’t know how the contestants are doing it from week to week. It seems that every week the judges give them conflicting criticism…one week they are singing too young…the next week too old. One week they didn’t connect with the song, the next week the judges just don’t “get” it. It’s a wonder these folks can even get up there and sing with any confidence at all! I agree with the post that the judges comments should be muted. Contrary to what Ellen says every critique, I don’t believe everyone is “great” and “adorable”.

By: Julie

Julie — Fri, 12 Mar 2010 01:27:05 +0000

I was NOT impressed with Andrew Garcia, and am rooting for 4 contestants: Alex, Lilly, Casey, and Lee, in no particular order. They all have so much potential. Also, the girl who hit the crazy note, I won’t try spelling her name, I know I’ll butcher it. Everyone else can pack their bags.. please.

By: Lynda

Lynda — Thu, 11 Mar 2010 22:10:08 +0000

Every time I see Kara hanging all over Simon, I want to throw up. This year the judges are more distracting than anything else. I’m going to follow the Sara’s advice next week. As for the contestants, I really think Casey is the best of the guys. I, too, think the judges have been really unfair to him, first falling all over themselves to praise him and now shunning his performances. I used to admire Simon and Randy for their honest opinions, but not this season. In fact, all the judges need to be replaced if you ask me.

By: A Thought.

A Thought. — Thu, 11 Mar 2010 21:02:04 +0000

Kara, Kara – what are you doing? You need to be voted off. Your poor husband! What an embarresment you must be to that man – hanging all over Simon and trying to cry like Paula did. Go home and write your songs – PLEASE!

By: Lovin' it.

Lovin' it. — Thu, 11 Mar 2010 16:52:06 +0000

Well the guys did not step up! Better talent for the gals – but that is not saying much. Any of the guys could be sent packing tonite. I did not get Bike Mikes performance and Kara’s tears! A Paula wanna-be? Good Grief! What a loser of a judge! My fav was Alex. Going home, Tim and Todrick or Alex and Todrick or any of them really.

By: Sara Lawson

Sara Lawson — Thu, 11 Mar 2010 16:52:03 +0000

I mean this with no meanness intended….I issue a challenge to every person on here. Next week watch the singers, but when the judges speak mute the t.v. I really feel like people are listening too much to the judges. Judge off your own instincts and own opinions. I have actually found myself influenced by what they say sometimes even when I difn’t agree. I would hear what they said and say oh i could see why they think that. Try it people….see how many times you agree or disagree with the judges without hearing what they say until you’ve formed your own opinion. I was actually surprised.

By: PHYLLIS G.(LAS VEGAS, NV)

PHYLLIS G.(LAS VEGAS, NV) — Thu, 11 Mar 2010 16:09:56 +0000

I JUST LOVE THIS BLOG…..UNFORTUNATELY FOR ME LAST NIGHT MY DVR DIDN’T TAPE AI…..VERY DISAPPOINTED. SO THANKS FOR THE REVIEWS….I’LL BE WATCHING TONIGHT….I’M NOT TAKING ANY CHANCES…..DID THEY MENTION WHO THE GUEST PERFORMER WILL BE TONIGHT?

By: Williams

Williams — Thu, 11 Mar 2010 15:16:54 +0000

Hmm i dont get it about mike performing i did listen to it again and again and stil think it sucked. But he got perfect reviews so he wont be going home i guess. So the ones going home wil be A and A, Alex and Andrew they both did terrible. Anyway we wil see

By: carmend15

carmend15 — Thu, 11 Mar 2010 15:06:14 +0000

I really don’t get why everyone likes Lee. He sounds like every other rocker out there. No uniqueness whatsoever. I still like Alex, even though his nerves are clearly still present. I definitely see more talent in the girls this year. Mike was great as usual, very soulful and a wonderful falsetto. Todrick has a great voice, but I agree with Simon in that he needs to be on Broadway. I liked his version of the Queen song though. Tim Urban still needs to go away. I agree that he improved and he put on his best performance when he needed it the most, but he just doesn’t compare to the other talent.