I support this all of the way for her to be the next american idol judge.

One of the things that made them so amazing is how they would improve from week to week, and finally become an experienced professional. The progressed and improved their look, their choice of song, their style and even their voice by contructive criticisms from the judges. Even Paula was able to give good advice to everyone.

Those that took this advice and improved fast enough went on to the finals and perhaps became a successful professional in the business.

Bottom line, I think you have to have singing professionals to judge singers (and YES I thought Shania was excellent). But right now, I’m really not sure about Ellen. Yes, she knows how to entertain as a comedian and talk show host (personally I love watching her), but the jury is out on what she knows about singing and the music industry.

When Simon leave after this season, it would be great if they found someone that was an executive in the music industry that really had an experiences eye and ear for talent. Yes, they can replace Simon. But they need to do it from within the business.

I was wondering if the episode that Shania played the role of a judge your show, will be airing again with Shania herself as judge. I missed and I am big fan of hers. I cannot watch it on my computer as I do not have the computer and equipement to do. I was wondering if I can get a copy of that episode that would be great or if anyone else could that would be great too. I have met Shania in the past. I know alot of her familly members. I have a disability called hydrocephalus, but regarless usually remember all of her lyrics and it didn’t take me long to them. I have had four or five surgery upto now, but it’s not the same anymore as I since last shunt which a tube that drains the fluid. I am now using a walker, and will be moving to Ottawa just for a little in Rehabilitation Centre. I have done some recording in the past and I have my own cd. I started poems until later as an adult had attended vocal lessons, and music therapy. I know composed my own have some recorded and have two cd of my own. I was offered instaneously to do some more recording soon. I was expecting this person to give me her card to her business, which is music recording studio of her own. Her name is Leslie-Anne Dupuis.¨Prior to doing the placement in which I had an average of 94%, I attended the conventions, and had got to be familar and converse with the attendeed and employers and employees way before then. I have also met her band members of Shania’s. I also find them very gentlemen like, and charismatic as well Shania herself toward their fans. Actually I just completed writing a book, and I worked the Shania Twain Centre on placement when I attended Northern College.I have had created a brochure collection some data info, on the internet and in biography, then had recomposed into my own words but still based upon the book, and handled interviews with the staff, as well as helped costumer, handled cash register only once, took charge of reception duties.ect… I connect to Shania as some ways when she was child and the environnement she was raised in. Well in case Shania finds out, I just would like to add my address in case. My current address is

[Editor's note: personal information removed]

As I will be recieving rehabilitation service but in a home setting environnement. Shania is an inspiration, she is the only person in which her relate to all my situation, throughout my life. I have met her in the past but none of the photos have turn out of her and I. I just recently was at her event here where i reside in Timmins, Ontario. I wish I could of gotten a photo taken with her, but a professional photographer, as when someone else takes the photos with my did they do not turn out. Shania, I wish the best of luck and I hope to meet again in the future. Also I hope they replay the episode of american that you played the role of a guest judge so I can have the chance to tape and rewatch it over and over again once I can do that. I hope to meet you in the future once again Shania and get to keep a photo of you and as a keepsake. I am also anxious to hear your cd in which I will purchase, when it comes out. I have also hear that you are on a volume hits cd and I am unsure of which one it is. Well Thank you Shania.To the American Judge and producers of the Show, I love your show and I have been watch since it first began. Bye for now love to you Shania, and judges and contestant. Shania you are such as great person inside and out. You are and I am sure that being a judge on the Show with Constructive Critism and sincerity, and your charisma, will be an asset on the Show. The producer has done an amazing job of creating this show, for people with disability, as viewers, singers, and writers, will benefit from this show in the long run. Every contestant that even makes an effort and does not get through, doesn’t matter about winning or losing, it takes guts to do that, and get up on stage and be strong, as person to hear the judges comment. I believe as a judge it can be difficult at times as they under pressure as well, when they must tell your their judgement and be observant your gestures, and your presentation overall. It is also to see how you take their comments and how you react to them. At the same when hear harsh comment by anyone of the judges, they may testing you or renforcing that you can prove them better in long run, on in other shows or contest else where. From your fan Lynne Morel

Chin up contestant if not now, in the future with practice you may get someone in life, hearing comment that critism, at times can make a stronger person in long run. If that’s your dream, try and try again and you may succeed.