We had a very short list of bestAmerican Idol performances from the Hollywood Week group round after a rather bland night on Thursday overall. Our list of worst group performances could have been far longer, but we decided to narrow it down to the truly terrible to keep it concise.
One of the most awful group performances for the American Idol judges last night came from Megan Miller, Spencer Lloyd, and Alyssa Siebken. They were not only off in their individual parts, but their harmonies were all over the place as well. Spencer was the best of the three, but we still probably would have sent all of them home. The judges, however, decide to keep Spencer and Megan, sending only Alyssa packing.
We actually included the next American Idol 2014 performance on our best of the night list as well as our worst list. That’s all because of Caleb Johnson, who absolutely rocked this group song. We think he was one of the best of the evening, but the other three guys were some of the worst. Only Caleb and C. J. Harris survived from this group, while Tyler Ahlgren and Matthew Hamel went home.
Also in our least favorites of the night was the drama-filled group of Jessica Meuse, Nica Nashae, Stephanie Hanvey, and Cara Watson. Although there are a few good moments, it is just a mess overall with forgotten lyrics, off key notes, and bad harmonies. Jess, the last minute addition to the group, sounds decent, but looks so uncomfortable it’s painful. We would probably have cut most of these girls, but the judges only decide to send home Stephanie. Which causes her stage mom to FREAK OUT.
What did you think was the worst performance of the Hollywood Week group round?