What happens when former American Idol runner-up Jessica Sanchez and a new American Idol 2014 Top 11 finalist Majesty Rose York happen to perform the same song within a few days of each other? Well, it means that we have to have a virtual sing-off to determine who did it better!
Majesty Rose took a big risk on Wednesday night’s American Idol Top 11 performances show by performing the Oscar-winning song “Let It Go” from Frozen. This song is a huge hit right now, and trying to fill the shoes of Broadway beauty Idina Menzel is not an easy task. We think the song ended up being a little too big for Majesty, although the American Idol judges gave her strongly positive reviews for the most part.
Just a few days earlier, former American Idol season 11 runner-up Jessica Sanchez also gave a performance of “Let It Go” at a charity concert at Madison Square Garden in New York City. Proceeds of the concert went to The Pinoy Relief Fund. While we think Jessica dropped some of the low notes in the song, we have to say we think she comes out as the clear winner in this sing-off.
However, let’s just be honest, neither of them really can hold a candle to the original. I mean, it’s Idina Menzel, who can really top her no matter how good you are?
Cast your vote who sang it best in our comments section below!