What better past American Idol contestant could you pair up with quirky season 15 singer Jenn Blosil than Constantine Maroulis? Especially when they give us a beautifully unique rendition of a classic Frank Sinatra song like “My Funny Valentine” for their Top 24 duet.
American Idol judge Jennifer Lopez thought it was the perfect duet with the two of them just off in their own world. Harry Connick Jr., however, felt the duet turned into a “shouting match” and didn’t like the arrangement for the song. Keith Urban, on the other hand, “fricking loved it” and thought Jenn Blosil dominated the performance!