American Idol 2009‘s new judge, Kara DioGuardi, didn’t take kindly to Paula Abdul‘s comments yesterday that having a fourth judge, “doesn’t work.” DioGuardi expressed her disappoint over the harsh words:
“Paula has a right to her opinions, but I was disappointed by her comments, and hurt that she did not address them to me in person.”
“I am proud of my contributions to the show, and remain excited about the rest of the season.”
Paula’s rep tried to clean things up by claiming that Paula had meant other fourth Idol judges. I’m not buying it. What about you?
Paula, get over it! You’re not #1 as a judge nor is Kara (although I have to give YOU credit for not looking at yourself on camera…Kara…you love yourself…you’re turning us off). Randy is usually okay, but Simon has the final say in my books!
I love Simon and Randy, but I get tired of waiting for Paula to voice her opion. I just want to slap her on the back and say spit it out woman. I just don’t care for Kara. I can’t get use to her.
i like kevin and joe
Thre one with the real talent for finding talent is Simon. Although I think he is a little hasty at times in the beginning. Like Danny Gokeys friend should have been in the 12 in my opinion.. Paula does have a hard time spitting out the words, but I love her.. She is compassionate.. The show was the best without kara…
Kara don’t fit with the show, with other judges, with …nothing. Is truth that Paula trays very hard to express her opinions in an elegant way, but in a way she is the salt and piper of the show because she is so unpredictable.
Why can’t all four play good together, like good little kids???
I like it just the way it was, ( without Kara ) !
And why shouldn’t Paula get a pay raise. She has been working in the bussiness before Ryan was out of diapers
I hate to say it, but I liked the show better without Kara. I don’t know why they had to add her. Why fix it, if it isn’t broke. The show no longer runs smooth, people are cut off, time runs over, the judges arguing takes away from the contestants, Just go back the way it was. No offense Kara but you shouldn’t have been brought into this in the first place.
I’M NOT SURPRISED THAT KARA IS COMING BACK…THEY NEED TO COVER THEMSELVES IN CASE PAULA DOESN’T….BUT I SURE HOPE SHE DOES COME BACK….PAULA, SIMON AND RANDY ALONG WITH RYAN HAVE A GREAT CHEMISTRY…..YOU KINDA LOOK FORWARD TO WHATS GOING TO HAPPEN WITH SIMON & PAULA……..JUST BRING BACK AI SOON…I’M STILL IN WITHDRAWAL………IF ANY OF MY ADAM LAMBERT FANS READ THIS…I HOPE YOUR HAVING A WONDERFUL SUMMER…..
Paula – Forgive & Forget – Only ‘Kids’ can’t work together!!!!
Kara brings a professionalism that the other judges don’t have. Paula, although a very nice person, I find (when I record the show) I fast forward through her comments, there like finger nails down a chalk board, not to mention all the same.
Kara is very professional in her role but she lacks what Paula adds to the group, kindness and empathy, which is a excellent mix with Simon and Randy. Kara does not bring anything beside being a fourth judge that is not needed.
keep paula away from american idol 2010 she was mad as a hatter the last three series you dont need her to have a good show good riddance i say
So disappointed to think Paula may not be coming back. She gives the contestants kindness and empathy, and after Simon gets through with them, they really need it sometime.
As for Kara, she adds nothing! I say get rid of her and keep Paula. Besides, they don’t need a fourth judge. If AI dosen’t offer Paula what she wants, I think they are making a biggggggggg mistake.
I am very disappointed that Paula won’t be back,as she added to the success of the show.
Actually,I found last season for me,not as interesting with the 4th seat taken.
I know that Paula will have continuted growth in the public arena.
Mistake,with adding Kara.
anyway my best judge is Simon Cowell, he always speaks right opinion every contestant but sometimes he is rude too but I like him, anyway he is good and also Randy and Ryan, Paula to much nice to the contestant even she knows they don´t sing very well:( to be a judge they have to tell the truth so every contestant will learn their mistakes and change it to the better right folks??? my other opinion it’s too crowded to have 4 judges it´s too much for the contestants……:(:(
HI SHERRY & BABS……NICE TO SEE FAMILIAR NAMES….
I AM VERY DISAPPOINTED THAT PAULA IS NOT COMING BACK…..I LOVED HER AND SIMON’S INTERACTION….KARA …WHAT CAN I SAY….KARA IS KARA AND FRANKLY A LITTLE BORING……BUT IF YOU WATCH SO YOU THINK YOU CAN DANCE…RUMORS ARE FLYING THAT SHE MIGHT GO ON THAT SHOW AS A JUDGE…..BUT I’LL BE FRONT AND CENTER WHEN IDOL RETURNS WITH OR WITHOUT PAULA……
I live for American idol each year. It is my January doldrums fix.The show will not be the same without Paula. Simon had said that trust me, Paula WILL be here next year so I am waiting for him to take leadership and make Paulas salary competitive with others that are on the show.
Hi, I think that Kara is excellent for the show (and she can “SING” which is what it is all about) derserves to stay. Paula just needs to get over herself and realise that there are other people out there that are more capable of doing the job. If the Producers decided to pay Ryan more than Paula then she needs to take this issue up with them and not direct her unprofessionalism and insecurities towards Kara.Simon and Randy are the Bomb and they must stay too. Anyway it really does not matter who goes or stays as they say “The show must go on” Cheers to all.
LOve Paula always. No American Idol ,if we not have Paula. She is very veri good and talented person. Paula..Paula!!
Paula eres una persona muy talentosa, y en Argentina te amamos.Sin tu presencia el programa sería incompleto. TE QUEREMOS DE ARGENTINA
I was soooo happy to see your name, I missed chatting with you and I still LOVE ADAM!!!! I read everything I can about him and my daughter and I are looking at tickets to see Idol live just so we can see him – waiting for a show in Connecticut where we can get decent seats.
As for Paula, I agree it won’t be the same without her – she did have more to say that I agreed with this year, but she can be so dimwitted sometimes…. I think it does add to her charm though. I have looked forward to how she looks each week, as she changes a lot – hair, makeup, clothing styles, etc. But she does need to be a little more forthcoming with the honest opinion, and not smooth coat everything.
I do love the chemistry between Simon and Paula, and I love Simon for his honesty – sometimes too much honesty, and I think he has been wrong a few times, but mostly I agree with him. Randy is funny and mostly good with comments. Kara is OK, trying too hard to come across sure of herself, and sometimes a little wacky. The show will not be quite the same without Paula, and I will miss her, but I will watch anyway. I am wondering who can come close to ADAM and how many wanabees there will be.
I hope you are enjoying your summer – and I will look for your comments and interactions in January as well.
As for Paula’s comments about the fourth judge, I think she meant it for Kara, there has to be hard feelings- and she should know by now when to keep quiet. Honestly, she must feel that she was replaced. They didn’t rush to offer her a contract and more money, so she thought, “I’ll show them, I will quit.” and they are OK with that. That is my opinion for what it is worth.
I hope to see more of our “old buddies” on this site.
So nice to see your names PHYLLIS, and SHERRY & BABS>
I think things were going great with Simon, Randy and Paula, It was great when they added guest judges. They didn’t need apermanent 4th one. Kara just doesn’t fit in. Why wouldn’t you give a raise to Paula !!! That was like a slap in the face. Plkease bring her back AI. She brought so much warmth and tenderness that the contestants need beside the harsh critcism. Granted she had a hard time saying that they were awful, when they were, but she was just being kind. I admire that. Please don’t let Paula slip away !!!
IT WAS SO NICE TO HEAR FROM MY ADAM FANS…..I AM REALLY LOOKING FORWARD TO THIS SEASON….YES, I WILL DEFINITELY MISS PAULA BUT I HONESTLY LOVE THE SHOW AND ITS FANS..
UNFORTUNATELY, THE IDOL SHOW IS NOT COMING TO VEGAS THIS YEAR SO I;LL HAVE TO WAIT FOR WHEN ADAM GETS HIS OWN SHOW HERE, WHICH I;M SURE WILL BE IN THE NEAR FUTURE….. JORDAN SPARKS IS HERE ALL THE TIME…..YOU MUST LET ME KNOW HOW THE SHOW IS IN CONNECTICUT. I DO KNOW THAT HIS NEW CD IS COMING OUT IN THE FALL…..
EMAIL ME AND LET ME KNOW HOW THE SHOW WAS…email@example.com LOVE TO HEAR FROM YOU.
ENJOY THE REST OF THE SUMMER.
I knew when they brought in kara they were grooming her to replace Paula. 4 judges did disrupt the flow of the show. I would have bet money Paula wouldn’t be back this year. Too bad I did enjoy Paula loopy comments. She had style and grace. Karas good but I feel she can’t fill Paulas shoes. American Idol will find out they made a mistake. Maybe Simon should have given her some of his money. He certainly makes enough. Come on
Kara is boring and repetitive. Who needs her. Paula adds excitement and fun. I do not like Kara. I do not think many other people do either. What the heck is going through the heads of the executives that would allow Paula to go and keep that bland ho hum judge. Paula was correct, THERE WAS NO NEED TO HAVE 4 JUDGE. Bring Paula back!!!!!!!
PAULA en Argentina todos te queremos , POR FAVOR Q
particularmente quiero que este Paula en este nuevo American Idol, sin ella sería un jurado incompleto. VAMOS PAULA ARRIBA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
paula randy and simon are the ones we want not anyone else the show will not go as good as long as you mdont get paula back
As if losing Paula wasn’t bad enough, just look who’s staying, KARA the BIG mouth without a filter. Don’t know if I’ll watch the show next season, even with Ellen as a judge. Last season I stayed tuned in because of Adam Lambert,was shocked when he did’t win. The show just won’t be the same. As with so many shows, like Jon and Kate + 8, (as of Nov 2, will be changed to Kate + 8, has already lost 9 million viewers. I think American Idol will lose as well.
i feel that we the Home viewers and audience should let Kara show her abilities in judging the contestant.as we all know she is a brilliant singer and a world class songwriter.it is not all about.how long you stay in the show.it is all about how to judge/criticize contestant. and it is also the contestant’s advantage because of the well criticize they received,they now know where the problem is..so that when they are on the industry..they have the guts..to showcase their vocal abilities….and if the contestant after leaving the show became a successful
star on the Hollywood..it is the judges that makes them well prepared!
and that’s my personal opinion on this issue
but we dont like u kara or who eva ur stupid and retarded and dont kno what to do…u think u do but u jus messin up everything american idol is not goin to be the same:(( sorry eitha way no one is goin to like u bein on the show…its always goin to be PAULA…RANDY…SIMON…and no one else i love them and they will always be the best judges for american idol
HUBBY AND I,BELIEVE SIMON IS THE BEST JUDGE,AND RANDY IS A FAIR AND HONEST JUDGE, BOTH ARE PROFESSIONAL TAKING ON THE TASK OF GROOMING AND JUDGING OUR YOUNG TALENTED SINGERS. AND THEY KNOW WHAT THEY SAY,WILL HELP THEM,GOOD OR BAD.ELLEN IS A GREAT JUDGE SHE SOFTENS THE BLOWS AT TIMES,CONTESTANTS ENDUR.AND LIFTS OUR SPIRITS AT TIMES WHEN THINGS ARE NOT GOING SO GOOD ON THE SHOW.SHE IS GREAT JUDGE!! AMERICAN IDOL, IS ABOUT RARE TALENT,TEACHING THE YOUNG THAT YOU CAN DO ANYTHING AND DREAMS DO COME TRUE.YOU JUST HAVE TO WORK HARD FOR IT! KARA STARTED THROWING SEX IN THERE WITH ALL OUR YOUNG PEOPLE WATCHING AT HOME, AND SOME OF OUR CONTESTANTS.TAKING SHIRTS OFF, SAYING CERTAIN OUT OF LINE WORDS, SHE WAS ALWAYS WORSE WHEN THERE WAS ALWAYS ANOTHER JUDGE TO JOIN IN HER SEXEST GAME.SHE REALLY PLAYED CASEY! AND I BELIEVE HURT HIS CHANCES ALSO ON PERFORMANCES SOMETIMES.SHE TRIED MIMICK SIMON AT TIMES DUE TO LACK OF KNOLEDGE MAYBE.SHE TRIES TO DRESS AND DANCE AND MOVE TO THE MUSIC LIKE PAULA AT TIMES BUT IT LOOKS PHONEY, PAULA DANCED WITH DIGNITY AND GRACE! MAYBE SHE COULD GIVE KARA SOME LESSONS.ALSO, DID NOT GO OVER VERY WELL.I THINK SHE MAY HAVE A IDENTITY CRISIS.SHE NEEDS TO GO.SHE DOES NOT ADD TO THE SHOW SHE DEFAMES IT.OUR YOUNG PEOPLE WATCHING AND IDOL CONTESTANTS DO NOT NEED SEX THROWED IN TO SOMETHING SO GOOD FOR OUR YOUNG PEOPLE.AND WE AS FANS DO NOT WANT TO WATCH OR IT ANYMORE.GOODBYE KARA! WE VOTE YES TAKE HER OFF THE SHOW!
WE ALSO LOVE PAULA!BUT WE LOVE ELLEN,RANDY AND SIMON!! ALL WONDERFUL PEOPLE!
four can never play well together my daughter has twins freinds they get along well put the 4th freind in they fight ? well i heard jennifer lopes and steve tyler and rand love it great move ,.
ellen did her best you cansee she hate to hurt someones feelings she right when she ( may have said this) it was way to much on her plate with her tv show and doing america idol
Hey 3 judges is enough
country & western singing judge
R & B/Rap judge
Rock & Roll/heavy metal judge
I miss Paula,
80% of the time Simon was right..
Finally, AI realized KARA had to go, to late though, I think the damage as already been done. I wish American Idol all the best for the upcoming season. It was my favorite show at one time.
This show will go down since Simon is leaving. It just wont be the same. It will loose ratings.
Paula is the BESTH.
No doubt ratings will diffinately drop with Simon's departure. I really believe bringing on a 4th judge was Idol's demise, the oringal 3 were perfect. I used to DVR the show just so a could fast forward whenever Kara, the attention seeker, open her mouth. Paula left, and Kara stayed, big mistake. I won't be watching this season, why would I? The show won't the same one I've been watching since the start. Can't wait to see what Simon's new adventure is. Maybe we'll even see Paula involved, as well as Randy, one never knows.
i cant believe kara mite not be here for american idol season 2011. i dont care about anyone else just kara she is my favourite judge