American Idol 2009 Top 8 Elimination Results – April 8, 2009

Tonight on American Idol 2009, the elimination results for this season’s Top 8 will be revealed. Stay tuned…

So far this week’s bottom three are: 1 – Anoop, 2 – Scott, 3 – ~~Lil~~

Ryan says that Lil Rounds is safe this week. Either Anoop or Scott will have to sing for his life. Ryan announces it is Scott and he’s singing for his Idol-life. Will the judges save him? Nope. Scott has been eliminated.

American Idol 2009 Top 8 Elimination Results:

Scott MacIntyre

What do you think? Should Scott have been eliminated? He’s got a great spirit, but he just wasn’t Idol material for me. What about you? Let’s hear your comments.

Subscribe to get free American Idol updates on Facebook, Twitter, RSS, & Email

Ryan

I agree with Gina. I think Scott should’ve stayed(and yes, I had tears rolling down my eyes when Scott got booted off cause he was one of my finalists)cause he is an inspirational contestant. His determination to stay dispite of his disability should’ve touched everyone…but sadly this did not happen. Overall, in my mind, he did well and he had a good run, so props to him.

I think Adam is too flashy, with his outfit and singing style, dispite what everyone is saying. You guys can argue all you want about Adam being the best and should be the next American Idol, but in my mind, he should be kicked out, next Kris, then…Matt. I think Allison will have a good run with Danny, Lil, and Anoop. In the end it will be Danny! Danny all the WAY!!! even if Adam managed to make it to the final round against Danny, He will not match Danny’s determination and ability to recover previous crappy rounds because my prediction is that Adam will become very prideful due to his previous outstanding performance that he will screw up on his last performance…

On the other hand, if Allison goes head to head wih Danny, it will be tight. Allison is a natural singer but she doesn’t go around being all flashy… She is only 16 but she can sing but she keeps her head down. Humility is the key man. Humility is key period. End of story
John

SCOTT IS AN IDOL,..A nice way to tell all the lazy people with perfect eyesight how much we are limiting our selfs…. Adam is OK BUT NOT BETTER THAN THE REST!! Anoop is a very nice guy, a good singer and a person with a good heart. His innocence did appear as if he was sucking up to that stupid kara. ALLISSON should be the next Idol….. GO ALLISSON!!!
Roman

Nyce performance by Flo rida.The lowest moment was Scott’s exit.But anyway he was still to go,America voted him out,so dont blame the judges!Anoop,Lil will still be part of the bottom three compared to the rest.
But you never know week in week out,we get surprises!
amariz

Oh get over Adam already! He obviously has had so much professional experience and no doubt he knows how to entertain. He should have BEEN done a record already and therefore DOES NOT BELONG on American Idol. Vote him off already..give the others a chance to start from nothing and make themselves a star..they all have excellent voices and star quality. If he goes, I guarantee some label will quickly pick him up due to his popularity and stage presence!
alan sylvia

Anoop did not deserve to be in the bottom 3. He blows away Kris, Lil and Adam. Adam is a screamer. Kris appeals to the females, but has no versatility. Judges know Anoop can sing. As a group they know what there doing. Anoop is a true minority. A lot more white Americans and African Americans voting for their favorites on the basis of skin color and not talent. Wake America. Anoop can sing!!!
mick scaz

are you all joking kara has it right when she talks about artistry its who can sell after the show and who has longitude in the business and on that fact (even though im a danny fan) only alison and adam will do the business in the future..just like other original artists like doughtry did…all the other will work in some shape or form but become a star..no way !!!!
josh

Scott looked abnormal to me especially when he opens his mouth wide.I know a lot of blind people who look normal. Scott is just so strange. Glad to see him go.
donald

Ray Charles,Stevie Wonder,Jose Feliciano paved the way for Scott.He will go far and should be fine as a recording artist.He deserves credit for his perseverance to overcome his disability and make it better than most sighted people.He made it a great show to watch.The others are run of the mill and I probably won’t watch the show anymore.
Pingback: American Idol 2009 Top 7 - The Week Ahead | American Idol 2009
hotshot

Alan, I must confess that Anoop can sing. Yet, his stage appearance is somewhat lacking. But, as you stated he can sing. If the American Idol is supposed to be versatile, I don’t think Anoop fits that mold. However, if its all about singing, Anoop is up there with the rest. Seems like the judges are looking for creativity and I think Kris and Adam are leading in that vain. Anyways, I did get your point and he can sing.
Ron

To go off topic for a moment have you read today that Simon might not be able to juggle 3 jobs and that through process of elimination he might have to leave Idol next year when his contract is up?
I think if Simon leaves they should get all new Judges, maybe not Kara, that have a fresh look on the show.
What are your thoughts?
newfan1954

To Ron: (I’m having trouble finding your post, but was notified via email of your “off-topic” statement…)

As much as Simon reminds me of fingernails on a chalkboard – he DOES give serious feedback. What he lacks in tact, he makes up for in substance. Randy and Kara have offered a more “toned-down” critique – but still laced with constructive advice.

Paula? hmmmmmm….. In the few times I’ve been able to discern what the H— she’s talking about, I’ve felt she’s been a royal waste of time. Last week’s “non-DVR’d golden performance of Adam” can surely be attributed to Paula’s petty prima-dona antics – eating nup precious American Idol time. Whatever she might have said added nothing to the artistic education of any of the contestants.

In my opinion, I vote to not can ALL the judges – just the ones that waste everyone’s time. ……… (open for interpretation…..)……!
hotshot

Ron, if Simon leaves it will really hurt the show. He is the best!!! Yes, he does lack in tact, but to me he is simply entertaining the world. I also think Randy is good as well as Kara, but Paula is strictly flowing out of emotions and not content. Sometimes if it doesn’t challenge her, she does good. Yet, most of the time she sounds like Charlie Brown Mother. Yet, I just think the loss of Simon would hurt the show. He plays his role extremely well. Then too, he and Paula may bring balance. You know two extremes working together. I don’t know! What does everyone think?
Eric

He just does not have what it takes. He can sing but not great.
Ty

Reading your comments I can’t understand why so many people feel that Scott should have stayed, he was OK but not great. I hope you don’t loose Simon off the show or Paula. I agree they bring a balance, Simon tells it like it is Paula well she does come across has being a bit off her head but at least it’s entertaining. By the way I’m from the UK so can’t vote but love the show.
mick scaz

lol
Pingback: American Idol 2009 Top 8 Results Show - The Eliminated Singer Is… | American Idol Season 9 Updates
Paula Jean

Can any help me I trying to remember the the name the Rocken Nures. She was in Chris Daughter Season……..can anyone remeber?
Paula Jean

I wish I could remember, but I can't and the dang site won't go that far back
Paula Jean

HMMMMMMMM…………….Help Brain Melt DOWN!!!!!!!!!!!!!

GET YOUR DAILY AMERICAN IDOL NEWS:

ELSEWHERE ON THE GTP NETWORK:

American Idol 2009 Top 8 Elimination Results – April 8, 2009