Who Is Going Home On American Idol Tonight? 5/8/2014

American Idol 2014 Top 4 portraits

The American Idol 2014 Top 4 have performed and only three can make the hometown visits next week, so who will stay and who will go tonight? The frontrunner to win this is no longer clear, but what I do think is clear is who will be heading home tonight (or is it?). Let’s get to the predictions.

Who is going home on American Idol 2014 tonight?

Definitely Safe

Jena Irene. She’s at the top of our poll and even though her night was mixed, she’s been solidly gaining steam for weeks now and I think it’s paid off.

Caleb Johnson. He’s never been in the bottom and he’s never had a bad performance. I think it’s he and Jena for sure heading home for the visits next week.

Probably Safe

Alex Preston. Alex had a great night last night. There’s still a tiny chance he goes home tonight, but I don’t see that happening. He’s never been in the bottom and America seems to like him, so I think he’ll round out the top 3.

Possibly Going Home 

Jessica Meuse. She was in the bottom two weeks ago and probably was there last week (even though we weren’t told), so I think tonight is her last night. And not to mention, her performances last night weren’t as solid as they have been. At this point I think it’s between her or Alex, but I’m leaning more toward her.

Who do you think stays and goes tonight on American Idol 2014?