Why Should Caleb Johnson Win American Idol 2014? [Op-Ed]

Who will win American Idol 2014? Will they go on to be superstars like Kelly Clarkson or Carrie Underwood, or will they fade back into obscurity after the American Idol spotlight clicks off?

American Idol 2014 Caleb Johnson

We don’t know yet which of the finalists will take home the grand prize for season 13. However, we’d like to consider what makes each of them special and worthy of winning. Starting with the guy many consider to be the current front-runner, rocker Caleb Johnson.

Caleb has consistently given great performances week after week since his initial audition. Honestly, we think he has been the most consistent singer of all of the Top 13 finalists throughout the whole season. We really don’t feel like he’s given a single actually bad performance. Maybe a few that aren’t as exciting as others, but you just haven’t heard the American Idol judges rip him up over anything because there is so little to negatively critique about his performances

On stage, Caleb looks so comfortable he could have been born there. Singing solo, he commands the venue like he’s the ‘viking’ Keith Urban has named him. In front of the house band, he comes across like someone who does stadium gigs for thousands all the time. None of the other American Idol finalists look just so at ease and confident on stage.

Caleb Johnson

Frankly, “Caleb Johnson wins American Idol 2014!” is a headline we wouldn’t mind seeing. It’s been years since a rocker took home the title, when David Cook won season 7 in 2008 over crooner David Archuleta. We think Adam Lambert should have won season 8, but alas, he did not.

Rockers have a hard time on the show, and they rarely ever make it to the final two. So we find it impressive and a testament to his talent that Caleb Johnson is almost certain to make the season 13 finale as it stands right now, if not win this whole thing. Even more so, and we aren’t sure how to put this in a nice way, because Caleb isn’t a traditionally ‘hot’ rock guy like David Cook, Adam Lambert, or Chris Daughtry. Although we certainly think, like Jennifer Lopez said, that Caleb can be quite sexy on stage when he gets into ‘rock viking’ mode.

So our biggest reason for why Caleb Johnson should win American Idol 2014, besides his obvious mad skills on stage, is that we just want to see another rocker grab the gold.

The past few years we’ve had the country winner with Scotty McCreery (and runner-up last year in Kree Harrison), we’ve had the diva R&B winner girl with Candice Glover, we had pop star in the making Phillip Phillips, and whatever Lee DeWyze was, we aren’t sure. And Kris Allen, bless him, the guy everyone seems to forget ever won. Maybe it’s finally time to give the trophy back to the rockers!

While the rockers who have won American Idol or done well on the show may not be quite on the level of Kelly or Carrie when it comes to fame and fortune, many of them have been quite successful. We think Caleb could achieve at least a strong Daughtry kind of post-Idol career regardless of how he finishes out the season, but winning would give him a very strong boost.




  1. If he can’t drop the front man in a tribute band schtick, he shouldn’t win. He has the pipes, he has the confidence but he’s stuck in a retro groove. and you can’t build a career on that.

    • Exactly. How about something relevant? I wonder what percentage of voters are under 35? Not many I’m sure. I think tribute band front man is in his cards.

  2. In my opinion Caleb has an excellent shot at walking away with title…Jena is not far behind him however, for the same qualities that Caleb has Jena has as well, she feels very at home on stage as well…and she can belt a song across the room with ease and as if she has been doing it forever! I do favor Caleb because I like his style of music and I think he is AWESOME! I have been behind Caleb since day one and I remain faithful! It will be an exciting final two shows that is for sure…because we all know….things can turn around and surprise us all.

    • “my” fav too!!!
      however they should interview “Both” Idols “neighbors”, (it might be funny)

  3. Bo Bice was a rocker that came in 2nd to the great Carrie Underwood. I believe the same will happen this season with Caleb Johnson coming in 2nd to the great Jena Asciutto!

    • Bo Bice is now the “voice” of the Great “Blood Sweat & Tears”, (and “killing it” every night!!!!)

  4. I think Caleb is a very good rocker. He has good stage appearance. He is so comfortable on stage.He does not scream when he is in his high range. I do not like screamers at all. We shall see who America picks. And I agree with Ms Turner. Caleb has given the most great performances through out this season. But how ever like she said rockers do not win too often. Also as she said Adam Lambert should have won! No reason to feel sorry for Adan though. He is raking in big bucks anyway.

  5. Caleb has earned the win . All good performances whether rock or ballad. He’s very confident and relates well to the audience. What more could one ask?

  6. Caleb is an excellent rock n roll performer among the idols, because that is his style and kind of genre!… But what I observed most… I don’t think he has “musicality”. I haven’t seen him play any instrument! If you are a real musician or artist you should at least play any instrument and can write and arrange your own songs. That’s aside from other flaws that I have seen in his previous performances. Anyway, this is just my opinion! I don’t think CALEB has the whole package! Sorry guys…but I just had a rain check on his capabilities and abilities!! But who knows??… We really don’t know!!!

  7. Celeb needs to sing a meatloaf song think he would bring down the house.

  8. To the question “why should Caleb Johnson win this year’s American Idol?” I think for someone to have to ask this question they must be living some where other than planet earth. The real question is: “Is American Idol ready and prepared for when Caleb wins; or will American Idol fall short of what could be the best and the biggest win ever of all its shows (and what part will Jennifer Lopez add to it)?”

Comments are closed.