American Idol Predictions: 2014 Top 5 Girls — Who Will Make It?

The American Idol 2014 results from Wednesday night’s girls performance show won’t be revealed until Thursday night, but the official voting has closed so let’s make some predictions on who will make it to the Top 5 girls on Season 13.

Majesty Rose on American Idol 2014
Majesty Rose on American Idol 2014 – Source: FOX

Instead of basing these predictions on our preferences or rankings we will be looking at your votes here in our Idol poll.

After just shy of a thousand votes, which is a terribly small sample size compared to the official voting, there are four clear leaders while two contestants are tied in 5th place.

Topping the charts? That’d be MK Nobilette. She had a strong performance and didn’t seem nearly as impacted by nerves as some of the other girls. Malaya isn’t far behind MK though and her happy-go-lucky personality could outshine many of the other singers this season.

Here’s how the rest of the Top 5 predictions breakdown based on your votes here:

American Idol 2014: Top 5 Girls predictions

  1. MK Nobilette
  2. Malaya Watson
  3. Majesty Rose York
  4. Jessica Meuse
  5. Kristen O’Connor

All the way at the very bottom is Marrialle Sellars tied with Bria Anai Johnson at just 2% of the votes here. She’s a great singer but had a terrible song choice. Don’t pick songs made for studio-magic like Katy Perry hits. They just don’t translate to live shows like this.

If Marrialle is at the bottom when the official results are revealed then I’d expect her to snag one of the judges’ wild card seats.

Who do you think will be in the Top 5 girls this week when Ryan Seacrest dims the lights on Thursday night?





  1. From what I saw, the top 5 girls will almost certainly include Malaya, Majesty, MK and Jessica. That’s four of the five identified by the poll so it looks like the poll was actually accurate for once. Before I looked at the poll results I was tempted to say the fifth spot would go to Emily or maybe Briana. I found Kristen’s performance kinda boring but she’s a good singer and she’s pretty so I’ll give her a chance. Ultimately, I’d say that fifth spot could go to any of those three. As far as wild cards go, Marrialle will probably get one because she’s a HPPF but MAYBE the judges will pick up on the fact that America isn’t a fan of Marrialle and won’t waste a wild card. I could also see them giving a spot to Briana if she doesn’t make it through on America’s votes, but probably none of the other girls.

  2. For my prediction of the top 5 girls, I would say that Majesty and Malaya have the best chance of going through with MK taking one of the spots as well. The last two spots I could see being Jessica and possibly Briana, even though their performances were not the best but they have more potential than most of the other girls. I want to say that I would give a wildcard spot to Jena because I think she has great talent, but for some reason I could also see them picking Kristen or Emily. Overall, I think rush week perfectly defines it because the nerves really got the best of most of them. Lets just hope America chooses right and Marialle is sent home because Kenzie should have performed instead of her.

  3. I wanted the top 5 girls to be Briana, Majesty, Jena, Jessica, and Kenzie but obviously since Kenzie is gone that won’t happen. I guess now instead of Kenzie, I would choose Malaya. MK is good as well and might make the top 5 girls instead of Briana or Jena, who should definitely be given a wildcard spot. Kristen has a chance too, but I can’t see them giving her a wildcard pick, if they think the guys performed better. Emily had strong vocals, but why would you choose that song when you know it was going to make the judges give harsh criticism. I was also not crazy about Bria who seemed to be over singing the entire song. Marialle has a geniune background story, but I’m sorry she is terrible and I don’t see why the judges even picked her to even be in the Top 10 Girls. She is good at moving around the stage, but the passion and vocals are not showcased at all.

  4. top 5 girls. Malaya,Brianna,Kristen,Majesty and Jena. Wildcard. Bria Anai & Emily. Mk is just symphaty vote. OMG Mariaelle i cant even spell her name she must be eliminated earlier in the auditions..jessie just ok..Austin and brandy must have been through as well..

  5. I don’t know who you polled but sure isntIt me or anyone I know, because we all cannot. Stand Mk or some. Of these girls. The guys they have chosen a re so much better. AMERICAN IDOL is not being fair to us who will be the ones voting. If someone like Mk wins she won’t be a star or selling many cds

    • although MK has a very good voice in terms of being on pitch and having actual emotion in what she sings

1 Trackback / Pingback

  1. TV ratings: Special 'American Idol' down; Olympics dip from 2010 | Steven Curd

Comments are closed.