Who Is Going Home Tonight On American Idol? 05/01/2014

The American Idol 2014 Top 5 took on songs America chose for them Wednesday night and there were some clear standout performances. But will those influence this weeks votes?

* UPDATE: Click here for our full recap of the Top 5 elimination results show!

American Idol 2014 Top 5

I think so. And all signs point to one unfortunate elimination. It’s time once again for us to look at how the votes might play out tonight.

Who is going home tonight on American Idol 2014?

Definitely Safe (No one is definitely safe at this point in the competition) 

Caleb Johnson. There’s no way that this guy is at risk. Not after his week-to-week consistency and his fantastic Whitesnake cover Wednesday night. I think we’ll see Caleb in the finale.

Jena Irene. I think this might be your final two. Jena has definitely come a long way, but I think she’s officially arrived. I’m listening to her performance of “My Body” from last night right now as I write this.

Most Likely Safe

Alex Preston. Sam did better than Alex in our poll, but I can’t bring myself to put Alex in the bottom two. I just don’t think America as a whole is picking Sam over Alex. Not when Sam already got voted out once, basically. I might be wrong, though.

Probably Bottom Two

Sam Woolf. Just like I said above, I can’t imagine Sam getting more votes than Alex, but we’ll see.

Jessica Meuse. Jessica has found herself here the past two weeks so I think she’ll be heading back. It doesn’t make sense, but we’re down to the Top 5 so it’s bound to happen to someone who doesn’t deserve it.

Possibly Going Home

Jessica Meuse. I think it’s going to happen. She’s last in our poll and she had the weaker song choices this week and like I said, she’s already been in the bottom two twice. Should she go home? No.

Who do you think will be heading home tonight on American Idol 2014?