American Idol Predictions: 2014 Top 12 – Who Will Make It?

Tonight the results from American Idol 2014 first round of finalists performances will be revealed and give way to the season’s Top 12 contestants. Let’s check out your votes so far to help predict who will be sent home on tonight’s show.

Sam Woolf
Sam Woolf on American Idol 2014 – Source: FOX

With over a thousand votes in our poll for the best performance of the week we’ve got a decent set of numbers to work with. There are some familiar faces leading again this week so tonight’s show seems unlikely to deliver any blindsides.

No surprise here to find Caleb Johnson rocking the poll with 21% of the vote. He had the pimp spot and delivered a grand performance that clearly left viewers with a great impression of the rocker. He’ll be far beyond safe with the results are revealed tonight on American Idol.

Next up we’ve got Sam Woolf at 10% and Jessice Meuse at 9% to round out the top 3 finalists. Here’s how the rest of the Top 12 predictions breakdown based on your votes here in order of their current ranking at time of publishing:

American Idol 2014: Top 12 predictions

  1. Caleb Johnson
  2. Sam Woolf
  3. Jessica Meuse
  4. Majesty Rose
  5. Alex Preston
  6. Emily Piriz
  7. Jena Irene
  8. Malaya Watson
  9. Dexter Roberts
  10. CJ Harris
  11. MK Nobilette

That final coveted seat in the Top 12 has a tied vote in our poll between Ben Briley and Kristen O’Connor. Only one of them can move on while the other will be sent home. So which one do I think it’ll be?

Update: Since publishing we’re seeing Ben climb up a point in the poll which leaves Kristen flying solo in the bottom spot.

American Idol 2014: Top 13 elimination

  • Ben Briley
  • Kristen O’Connor

Based on performances last night alone I’d say Kristen O’Connor is in trouble. I thought Ben’s performance was great, but if he’s tied at the very bottom in our poll that’s clearly not a widely held opinion. All the same I’m going to go ahead and predict Kristen will be sent home tonight on the American Idol 2014 results show.

Who do you think will be in the Top 12 this week when Ryan Seacrest dims the lights?





  1. yes i think its kristen who will sent home tonight. i dont like the attitude she showed last night during the critique time

  2. After Caleb, its #2 Jessica #3 thru #7 Emily, Jena, MK, Ben, Alex, ( any order ) #8 Majesty #9 Kristen, #10 Sam. #11 thru #12, Malaya, CJ, Dexter, that leaves 1 too many , so one of the #11 thru #12 will go home. My prediction Dexter, but it wouldn’t surprise me if either Malaya or CJ, really none of the last 3 sang well

  3. Again, someone is way off on their listening, or maybe tone deaf, perhaps invest in better speakers, Really, Malaya over Mk, and I don’t particularly like MK but she was the top four of the women, best was Jessica, Jena and Emily were close. Majesty stage presence is awesome, her voice doesn’t match, Kristen was on par with Majesty, while Malaya was not present for the show, perhaps another few years on her voice

  4. For the men Caleb was by far the best among women and men, but for the rest of the men besides Alex and Sam, not much to offer

1 Trackback / Pingback

  1. American Idol Predictions: 2014 Top 11 – Who Will Make It? - American Idol Net

Comments are closed.