American Idol 2015 Top 16 Rankings: Reader Results

The American Idol 2015 Top 12 will be revealed this week by at least Wednesday night if spoilers don’t get to us first with any segments taped in advance, but why wait to speculate? We’ve made our power rankings so now it’s time to see how you the readers have stacked up the Season 14 talent.

Clark Beckham performs on American Idol
Clark Beckham performs on American Idol – Source: FOX

Leading off the guys list from our poll has Clark Beckham, Daniel Seavey, and Nick Fradiani, respectively. Now that’s got me a little surprised to see Daniel up so high, but I guess the “cute factor” can really drive you far in this competition.

Looking down below at the contestants who could be in danger if our voters had their way we’ve got Quentin Alexander, Adam Ezegelian, and Mark Andrew bringing up the rear for the votes.

American Idol Top 16’s Guys – Reader Rankings:

  1. Clark Beckham (+0)
  2. Daniel Seavey (+3)
  3. Nick Fradiani (+0)
  4. Qaasim Middleton (-2)
  5. Rayvon Owen (+5)
  6. Quentin Alexander (-2)
  7. Adam Ezegelian (+0)
  8. Mark Andrew (+0)

As for the ladies’ poll we have Sarina-Joi Crowe, Jax, and Tyanna Jones taking the top spots with no real surprises here other than maybe the actual order of those results. Jax and Tyanna strike me as having the strongest staying power amid their competition, but it is still very early.

Joey Cook, Adanna Duru, and Alexis Gomez have the undesirable honor of placing last in our poll for last week’s best performances. Alexis had a high energy performance but goodness it just wasn’t a well done one. Adanna seems to just get lost in the mix for me. She’s obviously a fantastic singer, but I don’t think she can stand out like she’ll need to do to stick around. Oh Joey. I think Harry was right that she’s a unique artist, but the schtick is going to wear out fast and it may have already done so.

American Idol 2015 Top 16’s Girls – Reader Rankings:

  1. Sarina-Joi Crowe (+2)
  2. Jax (-1)
  3. Tyanna Jones (-1)
  4. Maddie Walker (+7)
  5. Loren Lott (+4)
  6. Joey Cook (-1)
  7. Adanna Duru (+5)
  8. Alexis Gomez (+2)

If the Judges had to pick one contestant from each of those Bottom 3 stacks then I’d say Quentin and Adanna would get the saves and a second chance on American Idol 2015. What do you think?

Compare this week’s rankings against last week’s rankings to see how your favorites are holding up in the Season 14 competition.

Source: Top 16’s Guys poll & Top 16’s Girls poll




  1. Schtick is a great word to describe Joey. I don’t understand her popularity. For that matter, I don’t get Daniel’s, either (besides the fact that other people think he’s cute.)

1 Trackback / Pingback

  1. American Idol Spoilers: Top 12 & Wild Cards Revealed - American Idol Net

Comments are closed.